IMDEA Software

IMDEA initiative

Home > Events > Invited Talks > 2026 > Beyond Traditional Peer Review: Disruptions and Opportunities in Scientific Publishing

Carlos Baquero

Thursday, November 19, 2026

11:00 302-Mountain View and Zoom3 (https://zoom.us/j/3911012202, password:@s3)

Carlos Baquero, Professor, University of Porto

Beyond Traditional Peer Review: Disruptions and Opportunities in Scientific Publishing

Abstract:

In today’s world, we are witnessing several challenges to the traditional formats of scientific publishing as a mechanism for sharing, validating, and receiving feedback on new ideas. These disruptions include over-reliance on metrics, predatory practices in publication venues, and metrics gaming by authors. Some of these behaviours not only hurt the development of science and add noise to the system, but also can ruin the career development of researchers. A second-order effect is the overload of the classic peer-review system. With increasingly capable AI agents, it looks as though the overload is poised to intensify, but maybe the same tools can also help transform the evaluation mechanisms and offer a fresh approach to replicability of results.